Matthew tells us that the star “stood over the place where the child was” (2:9). If a star, as we understand stars, were to stop directly over a house, that house would be incinerated, as would the rest of the earth. Therefore, the incessant articles attempting to explain the star scientifically—planetary conjunctions such as between Jupiter and Saturn in 7 BCE, Haley’s comet visible in late summer 12 BCE, supernovas, such as the one in the constellation Capricorn in 5 BCE, or between Venus and Jupiter in 2 BCE—misread Matthew. The star of Bethlehem is not about science; it is about the search for meaning.
The star of Matthew’s second chapter is not a star as we understand stars. People in antiquity did not know about thermonuclear fusion or even how big stars are. In the ancient world, stars were sentient beings, gods, or the souls of the righteous or angels. The star is thus a heavenly messenger, not a science lesson.

Amy-Jill Levine in A Beginner’s Guide to Advent (Abingdon Press).

Leave a Reply